Lithium Ion Battery VS Nickel Cadmium Battery: Which Battery is Better?

By Ufine, Updated on March 21, 2024

Share the page to

A lithium-ion battery (Li-ion) is a type of rechargeable battery that uses lithium ions as the primary charge carrier. When choosing between a lithium-ion battery and a nickel-cadmium battery, understanding their differences is crucial for optimal performance. This article provides a detailed comparison of these rechargeable batteries, exploring their characteristics, advantages, and limitations. By the end, you’ll have all the information needed to decide which battery is ideal for your specific applications, whether it’s for portable devices, power tools, or industrial uses.

NiCd vs Li-ion battery key difference: Lithium-ion batteries have higher energy density, lighter weight, and no memory effect, making them ideal for portable devices. Nickel-cadmium (NiCd) batteries tolerate extreme temperatures, cost less, and last longer in cycle life, making them suitable for power tools and harsh environments.

Energy density: Li-ion higher
Lifespan: NiCd longer cycles
Memory effect: NiCd yes, Li-ion no
Best for: Li-ion – electronics; NiCd – industrial tools

Part 1. What is a lithium-ion battery?

Lithium-ion batteries comprise several vital components, including electrodes, electrolytes, and a separator. The positive electrode, or cathode, typically consists of lithium cobalt oxide (LiCoO2), lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (LiNiMnCoO2), or lithium iron phosphate (LiFePO4). The negative electrode, or anode, is usually made of graphite.

During charging, lithium ions move from the cathode to the anode through the electrolyte solution, creating a potential difference. This process is reversed during discharge, as the lithium ions travel back to the cathode, generating electrical energy.

Part 2. Lithium-ion battery advantages and limitations

Advantages

High Energy Density: Lithium-ion batteries offer a high energy density, meaning they can store a substantial amount of energy in a compact size. This makes them ideal for portable devices where space is limited.
Lightweight: Li-ion batteries are relatively lightweight compared to other rechargeable battery types, making them suitable for mobile devices.
No Memory Effect: Unlike other batteries, lithium batteries do not suffer from the memory effect. This means they can be charged and discharged anytime without impacting their overall capacity.
Fast Charging: Lithium-ion batteries charge quickly, enabling you to minimize downtime and keep your devices powered up.
Low Self-Discharge: Li-ion batteries have a low rate, meaning they retain their charge for extended periods when not in use.

Limitations

Limited Lifespan: Li-ion batteries have a limited lifespan, typically lasting between 2 to 3 years before their capacity starts to degrade. Over time, you may notice a decrease in their ability to hold a charge.
Safety Concerns: While rare, Li-ion batteries can experience thermal runaway, where the battery overheats, potentially leading to fires or explosions. Proper handling, storage, and charging practices mitigate these risks.
Higher Cost: Li-ion batteries are generally more expensive than other battery types. This is primarily due to the cost of lithium resources and the advanced technology involved in their production.

Part 3. What is a nickel-cadmium (NiCd) battery?

A NiCd battery, short for nickel-cadmium battery, is a rechargeable battery type using nickel oxide hydroxide and metallic cadmium as electrodes. Nickel Cadmium batteries consist of a positive electrode (nickel oxide hydroxide), a negative electrode (cadmium), and an alkaline electrolyte (potassium hydroxide). These batteries employ a reversible electrochemical reaction between nickel and cadmium to store and release energy.

Part 4. Nickel-cadmium battery advantages and limitations

Advantages

Wide Operating Temperature Range: NiCd batteries can function in extreme temperatures, making them suitable for applications in harsh environments where other batteries might struggle.
High Discharge Rate: NiCd batteries can deliver a high discharge rate, making them suitable for devices that require a sudden burst of power, such as power tools or emergency equipment.
Long Cycle Life: Nickel Cadmium batteries have a long cycle life, meaning they can withstand many charge and discharge cycles before showing significant degradation in performance.
Low Internal Resistance: NiCd batteries have a low internal resistance, allowing them to deliver a consistent power output even under heavy loads.
Relatively Lower Cost: Nickel Cadmium batteries are generally less expensive than Li-ion batteries, making them more cost-effective for specific applications.

Limitations

Memory Effect: Nickel Cadmium batteries can suffer from the memory effect. You can reduce their overall capacity if you don’t fully discharge them before recharging. However, modern NiCd batteries and other battery chemistries, such as lithium-ion, have been designed to minimize or eliminate the memory effect.
Toxic Materials: NiCd batteries contain harmful materials, such as cadmium, which raises environmental concerns during the production, use, and disposal of these batteries.
Lower Energy Density: Nickel Cadmium batteries have a lower energy density than lithium-ion batteries. This means that, for the same capacity, NiCd batteries would be larger and heavier than their Li-ion counterparts.
Self-Discharge: NiCd batteries have a higher self-discharge rate compared to Li-ion batteries. They tend to lose their charge more quickly when not in use, which can disadvantage applications requiring extended standby periods.

Part 5. Key differences: lithium-ion vs. nickel-cadmium batteries

When deciding between Lithium-ion and Nickel-cadmium batteries, understanding the key differences is crucial. Each has unique strengths and weaknesses that make them suitable for different applications. Let’s explore how these two battery types compare across critical aspects like energy density, lifespan, and environmental impact.

Table: Nickel Cadmium Battery vs Lithium-Ion Battery Comparison
Aspect	Lithium-ion Battery	Nickel-Cadmium Battery (NiCd)
Energy Density	High	Moderate
Weight	Lightweight	Relatively Heavy
Cycle Life	Long (but degrades with age)	Long (strong cycle durability)
Charging Speed	Fast	Moderate
Self-Discharge Rate	Low	Higher
Environmental Impact	Lower (no cadmium; recycling still needed)	Higher (contains toxic cadmium)
Performance in Extreme Temperatures	Good, but can degrade in very low temps	Robust — tolerates wide temp ranges
Suitability for Electric Vehicles	Excellent	Limited
Suitability for Portable Devices	Excellent	Moderate
Cost-Effectiveness	Moderate to High (higher upfront cost)	High (lower upfront cost)
Memory Effect	None (no memory effect)	Present (can require full discharge cycles)

Chemistry: Li-ion batteries use lithium ions as charge carriers, while NiCd batteries use nickel oxide hydroxide and metallic cadmium.
Energy Density: Li-ion batteries have a higher energy density than NiCd batteries. This means they can store more energy in a smaller and lighter package.
Memory Effect: NiCd batteries can experience the memory effect, which can reduce their overall capacity over time if not fully discharged before recharging. Li-ion batteries do not suffer from this effect.
Lifespan: Li-ion batteries generally have a shorter lifespan compared to NiCd batteries. NiCd batteries can withstand more charge and discharge cycles before significant degradation occurs.
Environmental Impact: NiCd batteries contain toxic materials, such as cadmium, which raises environmental concerns during production, use, and disposal. Li-ion batteries have a lower environmental impact in this regard.
Cost: NiCd batteries are generally less expensive than Li-ion batteries, making them more cost-effective for specific applications.

Part 6. Recommended uses: Which battery is right for you?

Choosing the right battery depends on your specific needs and applications. Below are common scenarios where Lithium-ion and Nickel-Cadmium batteries excel:

Lithium-Ion Batteries: Best for smartphones, laptops, electric vehicles, and portable devices due to their high energy density, lightweight design, and fast charging.
Nickel-Cadmium Batteries: Ideal for power tools, emergency backup systems, and harsh environments requiring wide temperature tolerance and high discharge rates.

By assessing your priorities—whether it’s longevity, cost, or performance in extreme conditions—you can make an informed decision.

Part 7. FAQs about nickel-cadmium vs lithium-ion

Are nickel batteries better than lithium?

It depends on your needs. Nickel batteries, like NiCad, offer reliability and cost-effectiveness. In contrast, lithium batteries, like Li-ion, provide higher energy density and faster charging. It’s about choosing the correct battery for your specific requirements.

What is the difference between NiCd and Li-ion batteries?

NiCd batteries last longer in cycle life and perform better in extreme temperatures but are heavier and have a memory effect. Li-ion batteries are lighter, have higher energy density, and no memory effect, making them better for portable devices.

Which is better NiCd or Li-ion battery?

For portable electronics, Li-ion is better due to higher energy density and no memory effect. For power tools and harsh environments, NiCd is better due to durability and long cycle life.

Can I replace a NiCad battery with a lithium-ion battery?

Yes, you can replace a NiCad battery with a lithium-ion battery. Still, you must ensure compatibility with your device, and it may require some modifications for proper functioning.

Is lithium-ion battery better than nickel cadmium for power tools?

While lithium-ion batteries offer lighter weight and higher energy density, nickel-cadmium batteries can handle sudden power demands and extreme temperatures better, making them suitable for power tools used in harsh environments.

What are the safety differences between lithium-ion and NiCad batteries?

Lithium-ion batteries, while highly efficient, can pose safety risks like thermal runaway if mishandled. NiCad batteries, though less energy-dense, are more durable under extreme conditions. Proper storage and charging practices mitigate risks for both types.

How long will NiCad batteries last?

NiCad batteries can last several years or even decades if used and maintained correctly. Factors like usage, storage conditions, and battery type can affect their lifespan.

Are NiCad batteries illegal?

No, NiCad batteries are not illegal. However, due to environmental concerns, some countries restrict using cadmium, a toxic metal in NiCad batteries. It’s important to follow local regulations for proper disposal and recycling.

Why was cadmium banned?

Cadmium has been restricted or banned in some products and applications due to its toxic nature and potential harm to the environment and human health. Regulations aim to minimize exposure and encourage the use of alternative materials.

Related Tags: