Cylindrical VS Prismatic VS Pouch Cells : Which is Better?

By Henry, Updated on January 4, 2024

Diving into the dynamic world of battery technology, this article unravels the distinctive characteristics and applications of Cylindrical, Prismatic, and Pouch Cells.

We explore their merits, comparative advantages, and suitability across diverse industries, offering an in-depth analysis to aid in understanding these varied cell designs and their relevance in modern energy storage solutions.

Part 1. Cylindrical cells

Cylindrical cells are a type of battery cell characterized by their tubular shape, commonly recognized in formats such as 18650 or 21700. These cells are primarily comprised of a cylindrical casing with electrode materials wound in a spiral configuration, allowing for efficient space utilization within devices.

Advantages

Mature and cost-effective: Cylindrical cells have been in industrial production for over two decades, resulting in mature manufacturing processes and high production efficiency. This translates to lower costs and higher product yields compared to other cell types.
High energy density: Cylindrical cells boast an impressive energy density, allowing them to store significant amounts of energy in a relatively compact space. This feature makes them ideal for devices requiring prolonged usage without frequent recharging, such as laptops and electric vehicles.
Efficient heat dissipation: Their tubular design facilitates superior heat dissipation compared to other cell formats. This characteristic enhances safety during high-demand operations by minimizing the risk of overheating, ensuring prolonged battery life and sustained performance.
Robust and durable construction: The cylindrical casing provides structural integrity, making these cells more resistant to physical damage. This durability contributes to their reliability in various applications, especially in demanding environments like automotive and industrial settings.
Ease of packing: The cylindrical shape allows for easy packing and stacking within devices, optimizing space utilization.

Disadvantages

Form factor limitations: The fixed cylindrical shape might not be suitable for certain device designs that require flexibility or specific form factors. This limitation can pose challenges in applications where space constraints or custom shapes are crucial.
Prone to mechanical stress: In some scenarios, the winding structure within cylindrical cells might be susceptible to mechanical stress or deformation, which can affect long-term performance and reliability.
Limited capacity: The radial thermal conductivity of cylindrical cells restricts the number of winding layers, resulting in smaller individual capacities. This leads to the requirement of multiple cells in electric vehicle applications, which adds complexity and can result in connection losses.

Applications

Consumer electronics: These cells find extensive use in devices like laptops, digital cameras, and portable power banks due to their high energy density and reliability.
Automotive industry: Electric vehicles (EVs) often incorporate cylindrical cells due to their energy storage capabilities and thermal management advantages.
Power tools: Their ability to deliver high power output makes cylindrical cells a preferred choice in power tools like drills and electric saws.

Part 2. Prismatic cells

Prismatic cells are a distinct type of battery cell characterized by their flat, rectangular shape. These cells feature stacked electrode materials enclosed in a pouch-like structure, often composed of aluminum or other lightweight materials.

Advantages

Space optimization: Prismatic cells excel in space efficiency due to their flat, rectangular design, enabling snug placement within devices with limited internal space, such as thin smartphones and portable electronic gadgets.
Improved packing efficiency: The stacked electrode materials in a compact, pouch-like structure facilitate efficient packing within battery modules, optimizing space utilization in larger battery packs, like those used in electric vehicles or energy storage systems.
Ease of manufacturing: The manufacturing process for prismatic cells, involving stacking layers uniformly, contributes to streamlined production lines, potentially reducing manufacturing complexities and costs.

Disadvantages

Limited flexibility in form: The fixed, rigid shape of prismatic cells might pose challenges in accommodating irregular or custom-shaped spaces within devices, limiting their use in certain product designs.
Vulnerability to mechanical stress: The pouch-like structure of prismatic cells might be more susceptible to mechanical stress or punctures, potentially impacting their durability and reliability in harsh operating conditions.
Lack of standardization: The wide variety of prismatic cell models available in the market makes it challenging to achieve process standardization. This can lead to lower automation levels, significant differences between individual cells, and reduced lifespan in battery packs.

Applications

Consumer electronics: Prismatic cells are often utilized in devices like smartphones, tablets, and laptops due to their space-efficient design, fitting snugly into slim form factors.
Electric vehicles (EVs): Some EV manufacturers incorporate prismatic cells into their battery packs due to their improved thermal performance and ease of assembly.
Stationary energy storage: These cells find applications in stationary storage systems, such as backup power supplies and grid energy storage, where their ease of assembly and space efficiency are advantageous.

Part 3. Pouch cells

Pouch cells represent a distinctive type of battery cell characterized by their flexible, pouch-like packaging without rigid casing. These cells consist of stacked electrode materials enclosed in a flexible, lightweight pouch made from materials like aluminum and polymer laminates.

Advantages

Customizable form factor: Pouch cells excel in adaptability, offering a flexible form factor that can be customized to fit various shapes and sizes. This attribute makes them ideal for applications where space optimization and unique designs are crucial.
Lightweight and space-efficient: The absence of rigid casing results in pouch cells being lighter and more space-efficient compared to traditional battery formats. This characteristic is advantageous in portable electronic devices and applications where weight reduction is essential.
Enhanced safety: Pouch cells employ packaging made of aluminum-plastic composite film, which effectively minimizes the potential for explosions when compared to the rigid casing utilized in alternative cell types.
High energy density: Pouch cells are lighter, weighing 40% less than equivalent capacity steel-cased cells and 20% less than aluminum-cased cells. This results in higher energy density.

Disadvantages

Susceptibility to physical damage: The flexible nature of pouch cells makes them more vulnerable to physical damage or punctures, potentially compromising the integrity of the cell and its contents, leading to safety concerns.
Limited structural support: The absence of a rigid outer casing reduces the structural support of pouch cells, which might impact their durability, especially in demanding environments or applications that require ruggedness.
Standardization and cost challenges: Pouch cells face difficulties in achieving standardization, leading to higher costs. Additionally, the heavy reliance on imported aluminum-plastic films and lower consistency poses challenges for pouch cell manufacturers.

Applications

Smartphones and tablets: Pouch cells find extensive use in smartphones and tablets due to their adaptable form factor, allowing manufacturers to optimize battery space within sleek designs.
Wearable devices: Products like smartwatches, fitness trackers, and wearable health monitors benefit from pouch cells due to their lightweight nature and flexibility, enabling comfortable and unobtrusive designs.
External battery packs: Pouch cells power external battery packs, providing convenient portable charging solutions for various electronic devices, including laptops, cameras, and smartphones, enhancing their mobility.
Electric Cars and Bikes: Pouch cells are integrated into battery packs for electric vehicles, contributing to their lighter weight and allowing for more efficient utilization of space within the vehicle.
Portable Medical Equipment: Pouch cells are utilized in portable medical devices such as infusion pumps, defibrillators, and portable diagnostic equipment, where their flexibility and lightweight design are advantageous.
Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs): Drones and UAVs often incorporate pouch cells due to their lightweight construction, enabling longer flight times without compromising payload capacity.
Residential Energy Storage: Pouch cells are employed in home energy storage systems, enabling homeowners to store excess energy from renewable sources like solar panels for later use.

Part 4. The main differences between cylindrical, prismatic, and pouch cell

Physical structure

Cylindrical cells: These cells feature a tubular shape, utilizing a cylindrical casing with electrode materials wound in a spiral configuration.
Prismatic cells: Prismatic cells adopt a flat, rectangular shape with stacked electrode materials housed in a rigid casing, optimizing space efficiency.
Pouch cells: Pouch cells, distinctively, lack a rigid casing and comprise flexible pouch-like packaging containing stacked electrode materials.

Form factor and adaptability

Cylindrical cells: Known for their standardized cylindrical shape, providing efficient packing and good heat dissipation, but with limitations in custom form factors.
Prismatic cells: Offer a balance between space efficiency and form factor adaptability, fitting well in various device designs while maintaining a consistent shape.
Pouch cells: Highly adaptable due to their flexible structure, enabling custom shapes and sizes, and ideal for space-constrained applications.

Energy density and performance

Cylindrical cells: Often exhibit higher energy density compared to prismatic and pouch cells, suitable for applications requiring high energy storage.
Prismatic cells: Tend to offer moderate energy density, balancing space efficiency and energy storage, suitable for various consumer electronics and automotive applications.
Pouch cells: Typically have lower energy density compared to cylindrical and prismatic cells, but their flexibility and lightweight nature cater to specific portable applications.

Manufacturing complexity and cost

Cylindrical cells: Manufacturing involves winding electrode materials, which can be complex and potentially more costly due to the process intricacies.
Prismatic cells: Assembly is generally simpler compared to cylindrical cells, reducing manufacturing complexities and potentially lowering production costs.
Pouch cells: Often involve fewer materials and steps in manufacturing, potentially leading to cost efficiencies in large-scale production.

Mechanical durability and safety

Cylindrical cells: Known for their robust casing, offering better protection against mechanical stress and potential damage, enhancing overall safety.
Prismatic cells: Provide moderate mechanical support with their rigid casing, offering a balance between protection and adaptability.
Pouch cells: More susceptible to physical damage due to the absence of a rigid casing, requiring additional protective measures to ensure durability and safety.

Part 5. Conclusion

Each battery cell type – cylindrical, prismatic, and pouch – has its advantages and disadvantages. Cylindrical cells are cost-effective and have excellent consistency, while prismatic cells offer enhanced protection and simplified structures. Pouch cells provide high energy density but face challenges in standardization and cost. The choice of cell type depends on factors such as material characteristics, application requirements, and product specifications. Regardless of the cell type, safety is a crucial concern and adherence to relevant safety standards is essential.

Related Tags: